Skip to main content

Curated by Project Syndicate

Catalonia’s Ill-Fated Vote

4 commentaries

The police crackdown that Spain’s government carried out in Catalonia to stop the region's independence referendum has drawn criticism of both the Spanish authorities and Catalan regional officials for holding the vote. So when is secession legitimate?

Sort by: Show:
  1. Preserving Spain
    A child wearing a Catalan flag on his back SOPA Images/Getty Images

    Preserving Spain

    Sep 30, 2017 Ana Palacio argues that recognizing Catalonia's “right to decide” on secession would shatter the Spanish constitutional order.

  2. The Turn of the Kurds
    Ink-stained fingers in front of a Kurdish flag Safin Hamed/Getty Images

    The Turn of the Kurds

    Sep 29, 2017 Richard Haass proposes five criteria for judging the legitimacy of secession – and thinks Iraqi Kurdistan meets them all.

  3. The Who, Where, and When of Secession
    Students gather as they demonstrate against the position of the Spanish government Dan Kitwood/Getty Images

    The Who, Where, and When of Secession

    Sep 29, 2017 Joseph S. Nye, Jr. shows why the right of national self-determination falls short of being a primary moral principle.

  4. Is There A Right To Secede?
    Scottish Referendum Neil Winton/Flickr

    Is There A Right To Secede?

    Jul 9, 2014 Peter Singer considers the merits of Scotland and Catalonia's bids for independence.

Our Pick

Featured

  1. patten149_OZAN KOSEAFP via Getty Images_uyghurprotest Ozan Kose/AFP via Getty Images

    The Necessity of Morality in Foreign Policy

    Chris Patten shows why “realism” requires heeding the lessons of history and defending democratic values.
  2. velasco133_sUSAN WALSHPOOLAFP via Getty Images_bidenvonderleyen Susan Walsh/Pool/AFP via Getty Images

    A Subsidy War Without Winners

    Andrés Velasco calls on policymakers to avoid petty conflicts and work together to encourage green investments.
  3. taniguchi1_Tomohiro OhsumiGetty Images_abemilitary Tomohiro Ohsumi/Getty Images

    Japan’s New Security Posture Is Abe’s Legacy

    Taniguchi Tomohiko explains how the government’s ambitious defense agenda expands on the late prime minister’s ideas.
  4. mazzucato50_Andrea BonettiGreek Prime Minister's Office via Getty Images_popefrancis Andrea Bonetti/Greek Prime Minister's Office via Getty Images

    For the Common Good

    Mariana Mazzucato outlines a new governance model for ensuring a fairer distribution of agency, risk, and reward.
  5. lopes12_PIUS UTOMI EKPEIAFP via Getty Images_fossil fuel worker PIUS UTOMI EKPEI/AFP via Getty Images

    Helping Middle-Income Energy Exporters Kick the Fossil-Fuel Habit

    Carlos Lopes explains what it will take for resource-rich economies to diversify and develop new revenue sources.
  6. op_boccaletti3_Michele LapiniGetty Images_italyflood

    The New European Frontier

    Giulio Boccaletti

    Given this summer's climate-driven disasters, one might think that the European political system would be devising comprehensive adaptation plans. But, despite some steps in the right direction, Europeans are only just waking up to the constitutional implications of a changing physical environment.

    thinks a changing climate will force the European Union finally to embrace its political nature.
  7. james200_Sean GladwellGetty Images_worldconnection Sean Gladwell/Getty Images

    The Poverty of Anti-Capitalism

    Harold James considers recent arguments against markets, globalization, and growth, finding them to be deeply flawed.
  8. stiglitz314_ Drew AngererGetty Images_jeromepowell Drew Angerer/Getty Images

    How Not to Fight Inflation

    Joseph E. Stiglitz

    A careful look at US economic conditions supports the view that inflation was driven mainly by supply-side disruptions and shifts in the pattern of demand. Given this, further interest-rate hikes will have little to no effect – and will cause far-reaching problems of their own.

    sees little upside and much downside to further monetary-policy tightening by the US Federal Reserve.
  9. slaughter95_Ritesh ShuklaGetty Images_modi Ritesh Shukla/Getty Images

    Who Is Part of the Free World?

    Anne-Marie Slaughter urges US President Joe Biden to abandon a phrase that is better left in the twentieth century.

Edit Newsletter Preferences

Set up Notification

To receive email updates regarding this {entity_type}, please enter your email below.

If you are not already registered, this will create a PS account for you. You should receive an activation email shortly.