Comments 5

درسان للرئيس الأمريكي القادم

Oct 26, 2016 Chris Patten

ناغازاكي- عندما نظرت من نافذتي للميناء في مدينة ناغازاكي الرائعة في اليابان تبادرت لذهني فكرتان ترتبطان بشكل وثيق بالرئيس الأمريكي القادم .

لقد تحملت ناغازاكي أسوأ شرور البشرية ففي أغسطس من سنة 1945 دمرت قنبلة بلوتونيوم المدينة مسببة أضرارا مادية جسيمة ومعاناة إنسانية لا توصف ولكن منذ ذلك الوقت أصبحت المدينة تمثل أفضل الإنجازات البشرية حيث نهضت من الإنقاض بفضل روح وجرأة اليابانيين واليابانيات والذين تاجروا بالأشياء التي بنوها- على سبيل المثال في أحواض سفن متسوبيشي- مع بقية العالم .

لكن ناغازاكي – واليابان بشكل عام- لم تكن دائما مفتوحة للعالم قبل أن تعبر المحيط للتواصل مع جاراتها القريبات مثل الصين وحلفياتها البعيدات مثل الولايات المتحدة الأمريكية فلقرون عديدة كانت العقول اليابانية والحدود اليابانية مغلقة بشكل واضح.

We hope you're enjoying Project Syndicate.

To continue reading, subscribe now.

Get unlimited access to PS premium content, including in-depth commentaries, book reviews, exclusive interviews, On Point, the Big Picture, the PS Archive, and our annual year-ahead magazine.

Already have an account or want to create one? Log in

new comment has been posted. new comments have been posted.

0 Comments on this paragraph, 5 in all 5 Comments on this article

John Doyle Nov 2, 2016

The Japanese did the right thing to stamp out Catholic doctrine there at the time. Pity they then got the taste for colonial expansion, only killed off by Nagasaki and Hiroshima. Being open to the world can be a fraught exercise, and Japan should know it all too well. But they are now willing to exchange their representative government for the imminent corporatising world of the "Free Trade" treaties. Not good.
Fortunately, and the USA is powerless to reverse this, the current industrial dynasty is now, after 250 years on the slide, ordained to collapse. So any corporate victory will be phyrric. Whomever is president will not make a difference to this but they may make mischief as the economies crash. Deflation today, recession tomorrow and collapse are all ordained to occur on our finite planet. Have fun!!!
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
j. von Hettlingen Oct 28, 2016

Chris Patten's "two lessons" for the next US presdient are - to ditch isolationism and to learn from the 1945 bombing of Nagasaki. He says Trump's popularity among his supporters is a testament of "closed minds and closed borders" which is prevalent in the US and some parts of Europe. He hopes that "the more moderate" Hillary Clinton will defeat "the recklessly isolationist Donald Trump." But he fears that "the backlash against openness that has fueled Trump’s rise will not dissipate on its own."
Trump seems to ignore what inspired his German - not Swedish - grandfather to come to America. Frederick Trump must have been attracted by its essence of openness - especially an openness to a stranger, a sense of possibility, an embrace of future, and a readiness for adventure that no other country could offer. America's success has also its "diversity" to thank for - a "key strength" of the country. It provided "a haven for people from all over the world, where all people are subject to the same rules and law," embracing the motto: E Pluribus Unum (one out of many).
Unfortunately Trump's supporters aren't in the mood to celebrate America's success. They see it as sour grapes, as they can't reach it. Hillary Clinton will be well-advised "to address some of the real grievances that spurred the backlash against economic openness" and globalisation, which had lifted millions in the developing world out of poverty and created social and economic inequalities at home. Patten insists on an infrastructure programme, which would create "huge numbers of productive jobs and distributed wealth." This project "would be far easier to achieve if her Democratic Party also won the Senate." The US should rebuild its reputation as the “land of opportunity” - a quintessence of "US soft power in the past."
The second task for the new president would be to deal with "the overwhelming threat posed by nuclear weapons" based on the lesson learnt from Nagasaki, where Patten pens his commentary. He fears North Korea's "volatile regime, which is led by "the world’s most powerful juvenile delinquent," Kim Jong-un. While building a nuclear arsenal, it is "also working to develop long-range delivery capacity." Recent tests - last month's was the most powerful ever - show just "how close the Hermit Kingdom is to achieving its goals."
Kim has boasted that his long-range missiles could hit targets on American soil. Patten chides Obama for not halting Kim's nuclear activities and urges Hillary Clinton, potentially the next president, to take action. He advises against "unilateral action" and demands Washington "to persuade China to intervene to bring Kim’s regime to heel," which would require "some deft diplomacy," a skill that Trump lacks.
The author says the US has the obligation to protect its allies - Japan and South Korea - from Kim's nuclear threat. Instead of raising China's hackles by providing South Korea with the Terminal High Altitude Area Defense (THAAD), Washington should turn a blind eye to China's "illegal pursuit of territorial claims" in the East and South China Seas. while pleading with Beijing to consider a "more direct intervention in North Korea."
However, it's unclear whether the parties in these territorial disputes would agree on making concessions, just for the sake of "defusing North Korea's nuclear ambitions." Nationalism is on the rise across Asia. It would be a tough sale for political leaders to convince their citizens that a nuclear-free environment "would be worth the sacrifice" of waiving their claims.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
CALEB DEXTER Oct 27, 2016

*Addendum to the above*
This is NOT to excuse the METHOD that the Japanese authorities used to "stamp out the growth of Christianity in Japan" -- obviously, execution is NEVER an acceptable punishment for the non-crime of religious conviction. But the goal of the Japanese authorities at the time -- to allow Japan to forge a national identity as it exited the Warring States period without interference from outside influences -- was, I contend, the right one at the time, and laid the foundation for Japan's later success. It is, however, a true tragedy that the Japanese authorities at the time pursued that goal in such a grotesque, inhumane, and ultimately unnecesary way.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
CALEB DEXTER Oct 27, 2016

Chris Patten is as much an expert on Japan as Chris Pratt is on 3rd century Uighur animal husbandry. Japan is such a cohesive, functional country that can sustain a high standard of living for its people who "trade the things that they build" precisely because the country's leaders had the foresight to "stamp out the growth of Christianity in Japan" back in the sixteenth century. As a counter-example of what Japan could have become, look no further than the Philippines, which was colonized by the Spanish at about the same time that the Portuguese were trying to colonize,through their Jesuit missionaries, the Japanese. Today, the Philippines had a per-capital GDP less than a quarter as large as Japan's. Mr. Patten doesn't realize (or willfully ignores) that a country like Japan has one, and ONLY one, thing going for it: its people. It has no oil reserves; it has no fruitful agricultural land; it has no potash deposits. It has nothing except for the intellect and industriousness of its people, which Japan's rulers have been able to parlay into substantial wealth for its citizens and clout on the world stage. "[P]lurality and openness" can, indeed, be assets to a nation, but not always, and certainly not in the case of Japan. Mr. Patten would be wise to hunt elsewhere for an appropriate metaphor for his unsolicited words of advice to the next U.S. president.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Michael Public Oct 27, 2016

Hard to follow the thread here. What I am understanding is:

1. China should invade North Korea to help America out.
2. Clinton should detonate small nuclear bombs on areas supportive of Trump to promote a new culture of openness.

Of course I could be reading this wrong.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.

http://prosyn.org/wvHHgKD/ar;

درسان للرئيس الأمريكي القادم

To continue reading, subscribe now.

New Comment

Email this piece to a friend

Contact us

The Three Revolutions Economics Needs

Data-Driven Gender Equality

An African Opportunity for Post-Brexit Britain

Brexit Demands a New British Politics

The Right Investments to Address the Human Capital Crisis

Morality and Money Management

Cooperation for a New Age of Volatility

The Right Way to Rebalance Trade

Cookies and Privacy

Log in/Register