Shanghai skyline Shanghai skyline/Cezary Wojtkowski/Zuma Press

Long Reads

The Contradictions of Chinese Capitalism

Decelerating growth and financial-market turmoil have raised fundamental questions about the Chinese economy’s prospects. One problem many commentators rightly identify is policymakers’ inexperience with markets; more important, however, may be that the authorities remain in thrall to an unsustainable hybrid market model.

LONDON – The Year of the Monkey is well into its third month – and the rest of the world must hope that China’s authorities will soon start to live up to the monkey’s supposed cleverness. So far, the evidence is unconvincing. The Shanghai Composite Index dropped by 18% in the first two weeks of 2016, and has endured lesser falls since then; the renminbi has been on a downward trend since late 2014; and economic growth continues to slide. In short, it looks to many people as if China has lost the plot.

The critics – including commentators for Project Syndicate – have a point. The Chinese authorities’ brief experiment with a “circuit breaker” to suspend equities trading if the Shanghai index fell by 7% simply generated more panic in January, and the ouster of Xiao Gang, the chairman of the China Securities Regulatory Commission, amplified the uncertainty. Meanwhile, the Chinese leadership faces the daunting task of rebalancing the country’s model of growth from excessive reliance on investment and exports to one more focused on household consumption and domestic services.

But China’s problems may run even deeper. Much of the criticism of recent Chinese policymaking has focused on miscommunication with market actors: The key to establishing “credibility,” according to this view, is greater certainty about the authorities’ intentions. Andrew Sheng and Xiao Geng of Hong Kong’s Asia Global Institute, for example, believe that China’s recent financial-market turmoil is “primarily related to policy transparency and clarity.”

To continue reading, please subscribe to On Point.

To access On Point, log in or register now now and read two On Point articles for free. For unlimited access to the unrivaled analysis of On Point, subscribe now.


Log in;
  1. Donald Trump delivers his address to a joint session of Congress  Bill Clark/CQ Roll Call/Getty Images

    Trump’s Abominable Snow Job

    • In the 2016 US presidential election, Donald Trump presented himself as a populist who would protect America’s “forgotten” workers from the disruptions of trade and immigration and the nefarious designs of unnamed elites.

    • But, a year after assuming office, it has become abundantly clear that “America first” means workers come last.
  2. Project Syndicate

    PS Commentators’ Best Reads in 2017

    • For the first time, Project Syndicate has asked its contributors what they’ve been reading, and why. 

    • Their choices may surprise, but surely will not disappoint, readers seeking the most important books on history, politics, economics, as well as more than one novel.