Thursday, November 27, 2014

The Failed State of Egypt?

CAIRO – The aggrieved supporters of ousted Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi and the jubilant protesters who pushed the military to remove him have divided Egypt into two irreconcilable camps, both reflecting and reinforcing the country’s deeper problems. Indeed, Egypt is now largely an ungovernable country that subsists on generous foreign handouts.

Morsi never appreciated his tenuous position. Though elected democratically, he chose to govern undemocratically. He was bent on purging the judiciary and the public prosecutor’s office, claiming that they were aligned with the protesters opposing his government and their military backers, who had been overthrown in 2011. Morsi brooked little opposition in pushing through a controversial draft constitution. In doing so, he neglected to focus on the structural problems that propelled a docile society to pour into the streets two and a half years ago to bring down his predecessor, Hosni Mubarak.

Just as damaging as Morsi’s governing style was the Muslim Brotherhood’s go-it-alone mentality. Decades of persecution have instilled in its leaders the belief that the world is aligned against them. Assuming power only stoked their paranoia.

The Brotherhood’s leaders believed that the United States and Egypt’s elite were bent on ensuring their failure. For this reason, they refused to reach out to their secular opponents to offer them a piece of the political pie. Even members of the more puritanical Islamist Nour Party were not invited to join the government.

But it was not only Brotherhood politicians – inexperienced in the ways of democracy (and skeptical of them) – who stumbled. The debate in the US, long Egypt’s primary ally and donor, did not center on strengthening Egypt’s embattled institutions, but focused instead on how to ease the military out of power by withholding aid. Multilateral lenders like the International Monetary Fund were fixated on fiscal reforms such as reducing costly subsidies rather than shoring up a beleaguered economy.

Today, a democratic transition that the West sought to portray as a model that other Arab nations could emulate lies in tatters. Egypt’s economy, bruised by the outflow of foreign investment and a dearth of tourists, is on life support. Rebuilding the country will require much more than the cheering from the sidelines that Western countries have offered so far.

Egypt has always relied on munificent benefactors to sustain its patchy state and economy. After the military coup in 1952, the Soviets provided much of the needed aid. Their “technical” experts turned the country’s second city, Alexandria, into a Russian country club. After Egypt pivoted to the West in the wake of the 1973 war against Israel, America became its main patron.

But America’s ritual annual gift of roughly $1.5 billion could only dull the pain of Egypt’s problems, not resolve them. The country can no longer provide enough government stipends in the form of bureaucratic posts for college graduates. Egypt can only hope for cash infusions to offset its internal hemorrhaging.

By making aid conditional on economic reform and democratic transition, however, the international community risks political triage. It should instead focus on financial assistance that blunts Egyptians’ frustrations and that contributes to building the institutions that will facilitate the transition toward democracy.

But, of the $1.56 billion that the US State Department requested for Egypt in 2013, only $250 million is earmarked for non-military programs. The US should increase funding for projects that focus on governance, civil society, and strengthening the rule of law. Such programs receive a paltry $25 million in the 2013 budget.

To bolster the economy, the US needs to shift its aid policies away from funding projects toward providing immediate budgetary relief. Though financing water-efficiency schemes certainly helps society, its effects are felt years after the aid is initially dispensed.

The US, and other Western donors, should instead help Egypt to husband its resources, which are often misspent in an effort to placate its people. Egypt is the largest wheat importer in the world, and food subsidies account for approximately 2% of GDP. To preserve its precious foreign-currency reserves, Egypt needs the US and its allies to provide foodstuffs. Such a policy was adopted in the aftermath of the 1973 war, when America offered $200 million annually for wheat procurement. Embracing such policies will give institutions and the democratic process the time and space they need to plant firm roots.

Beyond such questions lies the fate of democracy in one of civilization’s most ancient lands. Whoever triumphs in future elections will lack the legitimacy that only a majority can provide. Such a majority spoke last year, when it elected Morsi. To strip him of his post negates a basic pillar of democracy and sets a dangerous precedent.

But, in a country that faces so many problems, the paradox of Morsi’s removal from power and the dilemmas of democracy that occasioned it are not among them.

  • Contact us to secure rights


  • Hide Comments Hide Comments Read Comments (6)

    Please login or register to post a comment

    1. CommentedMuhammed Saleem Ahmed

      The West is hell bent on whitewashing the coup in Egypt. Everyone seems to make us believe the Brotherhood is the villain, and to convince us employs all sorts of journalistic and intellectual acrobatics. It is a big show, now. In fact, The Biggest Show on Earth. But what puzzles me is will human conscience, wether the Western or the Eastern, can ever be deceited or defeated as the Islamophobes and The Devil's Advocates believe! International observers are barred from monitoring the Egyptian holocaust, Egypt's own journalists are shot dead ruthlessly, anybody heeding to the call of conscience (read al Baradaie) is threatened; but the West is still cosying up with their favourite bedfellows - the military putchists. But don't worry Arab revolutionaries are not dead yet and Egypt is not a failed state yet and it will not be. What best we can do right now is to heed the call of our innerself, our conscience, and support the oppressed people. It is better than insinuating the devilish idea that if Egyptian are not tamed with military aid, let us tame them showing some grass (wheat). God save the King and the Queen from the Western hypocrisy! Amen.

    2. CommentedSergio Barbosa

      Barak Barfi no menciona el tratamiento que Morsi dio a los coptos. La población egipcia es más religiosa que secular, por lo tanto, debemos de partir del choque entre el Islamismo y el cristianismo copto para entender la situación en Egipto. Una democracia no funciona en un sistema de gobierno basado en la religión. La democracia necesita un gobierno secular libre de prejuicios religiosos. Mañana, Egipto podría tener un presidente copto, pero si él gobierna como Morsi, la historia se repetirá. En Occidente muchos odios del pasado se han superado: Los Estados Unidos tienen un presidente que no es de la raza blanca y varias mujeres ocupan puestos de responsabilidad en varios gobiernos. Esto era impensable hace 60 años y que Egipto necesita una revolución de esta magnitud.

    3. CommentedAter Malekjok

      Egypt is not a failed state, she is in transition and this phase means, i'm free and i want Egypt to be rule the Islamic law, and other Egyptians say no, that is too late, we need a modern ruler would balance our faith and freedom we get from democracy. But, you for got that those country who are rule the faith are the weak states of the world. for 50 years of Egypt a faith never rule them because Egypt is a mom of Islam and of Egypt get history before her beloved son, Islam. So, Egypt is not a fail state and the whole world known that

    4. CommentedPaul A. Myers

      We should do a massive amount of food aid in Egypt right now, and then do more in the region. After that, we should institutionalize providing more food aid to the entire region because global warming and climate change are going to create great need. A wide horizon by western leaders is required.

    5. CommentedSergio Villalta

      Hmmm... so the only evidence to say that Morsi "...chose to govern undemocratically..." is that he purged the "... judiciary and the public procecutor's office..." Ok. Right. I guess that's his big political sin...

    6. CommentedJohn Doe

      why are you surprised that such small people live in the shadow of 4500 year old greatness. they have a culture of failure and truck no personal responsiblity

      Egypt is where it is because its culture society is incapable of re-inventing itself and has been that way for 3000 years