Sunday, November 23, 2014

India’s Second Wind

NEW DELHI – The Indian economy is coming back. After several years of disappointing performance, the authorities are shifting to policies aimed at boosting the annual growth rate closer to the roughly 9% level that India achieved from 2004 to 2008.

That won’t be easy. India has many handicaps and lacks many of the things that are needed to sustain rapid growth.

Although India has outstanding universities and technological institutes, the primary-education system is disastrously poor. The caste system and labor laws prevent an efficient labor market. The policy of quotas for lower castes and for members of certain “scheduled” tribes affects educational institutions, government employment, and even private firms. Populist policies that transfer scarce budget funds to hundreds of millions of rural men and women end up encouraging them to withdraw their labor services, driving up wages and undermining international competitiveness.

True, bureaucratic rules are not nearly as constraining as they were during the pre-1991 “license raj.” But business activity remains bogged down by myriad restrictions and a frustratingly slow judicial system, which, together with a complex system of price subsidies, encourage widespread corruption at every level of government.

Moreover, India’s infrastructure is inadequate for a modern economy. With too little electricity, blackouts are common. Ports are inefficient, roads are congested, and traffic is astonishingly chaotic.

And, while India urgently needs to reform its tax system, spending policies, and regulation, political change is difficult in a multiparty federalist democracy of 1.2 billion people spread over a large subcontinent. The current government is a fragile multiparty coalition. The Congress party leads the government, but lacks a majority in both chambers of Parliament. Coalition infighting and the prospect of a national election in 2014 further complicate efforts to enact reform legislation.

And yet, despite everything, India’s economy did record roughly 9% growth for several years, and even now is growing by nearly 6% annually, behind only China and Indonesia among major economies.

One key to India’s economic success is a large population of technically educated entrepreneurs, who are creating new companies and building a modern middle class. A high rate of private saving and strong inflows of capital from abroad have supported investment in plant and equipment. The Indian states have substantial policy discretion and often compete to attract businesses and achieve rapid economic growth.

The main ingredient needed to achieve faster sustained growth is increased investment. Reducing the budget deficit – by limiting government spending and combating a culture of tax avoidance – will increase total domestic savings available to invest. Convincing foreign direct investors that India is a reliable destination will increase the inflow of long-term funds.

Fortunately, the recent threat of a downgrade of Inda’s sovereign credit rating – which would have made it difficult to finance the current-account deficit – has led to a government reshuffle and a shift in policies. The key political change was the appointment of a new finance minister, Palaniappan Chidambaram, whose selection by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Congress party leader Sonia Gandhi sent a strong positive signal to the Indian business community and to financial markets.

Chidambaram, a Harvard-trained lawyer who has held the finance portfolio twice before, is committed to increasing growth and to adopting pro-market policies. He knows what needs to be done – and is pushing his political colleagues to do it.

One sign of progress is that a new cabinet committee, chaired by Singh, will review large private investment projects that have been held up by regulatory issues or other legal barriers. Breaking this logjam will be important, both in itself and for the message that it conveys to domestic and foreign investors.

Likewise, India’s recent decision to allow large foreign retailers like Wal-Mart to enter the market reflects an encouraging change of attitude that is important beyond the specifics of the particular firms that will now come to India. And legislation will soon create the opportunity for expanded foreign ownership in the financial sector.

On the fiscal front, the shift from a complex system of state-level indirect taxes to a national goods and services tax (a type of value-added tax) will improve efficiency and raise revenue. Lowering the subsidy for diesel fuel was politically difficult, but will reduce both the fiscal deficit and excessive use of diesel products.

Government investment in infrastructure, both alone and in partnership with private firms, will also directly benefit growth and attract larger inflows of foreign investment.

Finally, a remarkable plan to enroll every Indian adult in a program using fingerprint identification as a substitute for bank debit cards will allow more efficient distribution of funds to poor villagers and the urban poor. More than three hundred million Indians have already been enrolled.

All of this is an enormous undertaking – one that confronts innumerable potential impediments, both economic and political. But I am betting that India is rising again: millions more will be lifted out of poverty in the coming years, while the increasingly prosperous Indian middle class will expand further.

  • Contact us to secure rights


  • Hide Comments Hide Comments Read Comments (5)

    Please login or register to post a comment

    1. CommentedVaradarajan Seshamani

      The prime reason for the labour situation being inefficient, is the set of peculiar, socialist loaws that India has. Other factors that may be there are, at best, marginal players in creating problems in the labour scene. Laws are complex, there are multiple agencies, all of which exist simply to make the employer fulfil some procedural requirements and pay money and spend time. Indian laws are weighted substantially in favour of the 'worker' - even if he does not work. This has created a network of powerful, politically strong, labour unions, along with a web of officials requiring fulfilment of many rules and regulations that just stymie the operations of the straightforward, hard-working businesses and their workers. The nett result is inefficient labour administration, high labour administrative overheads and an inefficient and rentier class of workers at high cost, who cannot be easily removed from their jobs, even if they do not deserve to be there. Theree are many aspects of Indian business that cannot be written about with any level of sense, by looking down upon the scene from an ivory tower, but would need the plunge into detailed discussions and observations at the grass root level of work, where the 'vibrant' economy is being created or destroyed, as the case may be. I would urge writers on India to get down to the operating level, in trying to understand the country's business operations.

    2. CommentedSamir Singh

      Mr Anand Sharma, Minister of Commerce, Industry and Textile, Government of India shares his views on the recent economic reforms. Check out the view of Anand Sharma on Indian Economy

    3. CommentedPUNDALIK Kamath

      Professor, you say," But I am betting that India is rising again: millions more will be lifted out of poverty in the coming years, while the increasingly prosperous Indian middle class will expand further." Not so fast not so fast.
      You simply have not factored sickening rise in population, graft and corruption in all walks of society- mostly at political level-, increasing lawlessness everywhere, etc will not allow prosperity to appear for decades to come , not years!

    4. CommentedFrank O'Callaghan

      The danger of economic "liberalization" in India is that it could plunge the great mass of the Indian poor into greater poverty for the dubious benefit of "growth" in the wealth or a minority.

    5. CommentedSudhanshu Neema

      "Although India has outstanding universities and technological institutes ..."

      Ha ha ha, can't help laughing, you Sir should update your knowledge of India's "outstanding universities" and "technological institutes".

      However, I agree with your point of view that gradually India is progressing in the right direction and has good potential in the long term.