Kosovo Prime Minister Ramush Haradinaj (L) and his Macedonian counterpart Zoran Zaev

Comments 14

إكمال المهمة المطلوب تنفيذها في غرب البلقان

Jan 31, 2018 Guy Verhofstadt

بروكسل - عقد ممثلو صربيا وكوسوفو في 16 يناير / كانون الثاني في بروكسل اجتماعا لإجراء محادثات حول تطبيع العلاقات بينهما. لكن في نفس اليوم، تم قتل زعيم الأقلية الصربي أوليفر إيفانوفيتش في كوسوفو اٍثر تعرضه لإطلاق نار أمام مكتب حزبه في مدينة ميتروفيتشا شمال البلاد، مما أدى إلى إلغاء المحادثات.

ومنذ نهاية حرب كوسوفو في عام 1999، أحرزت منطقة البلقان الغربية تقدما كبيرا في مواجهة القوى القومية والرجعية التي أدت إلى نشوب هذا الصراع العرقي الوحشي. لكن اغتيال ايفانوفيتش، الذي تم على الأرجح على أيدي العصابات الإجرامية التي سمح لها بالازدهار في شمال كوسوفو، يهدد الآن بإشعال الأزمة بين صربيا وكوسوفو التي لا تزال قائمة. فقد خرجت الأشباح القومية في المنطقة من سباتها.

وتواجه بلدان البلقان الغربية العديد من التحديات الأخرى. ويرجع انتشار الفساد إلى شبكات الجريمة المنظمة التي نشأت عن الجهاز الأمني الشيوعي. إن تأثير الولايات المتحدة في المنطقة آخذ في الانخفاض، بالرغم من موقف روسيا الانتقامي. وبالنسبة لمعظم بلدان المنطقة، فإن الانضمام إلى الاتحاد الأوروبي ليس مؤكدا بعد.

To continue reading, please log in or enter your email address.

To read this article from our archive, please log in or register now. After entering your email, you'll have access to two free articles from our archive every month. For unlimited access to Project Syndicate, subscribe now.

Featured

MAD About Sino-American Trade

Sep 20, 2018 Minxin Pei
Good Politics, Bad Economics

Sep 20, 2018 Robert Skidelsky
Japan’s Successful Economic Model

Sep 20, 2018 Adair Turner
The Immorality of Boris Johnson and Donald Trump

Sep 18, 2018 Chris Patten
The US Will Lose Its Trade War with China

Sep 21, 2018 Anatole Kaletsky

new comment has been posted. new comments have been posted.

0 Comments on this paragraph, 14 in all 14 Comments on this article

Christine Constable Feb 9, 2018

Sadly forcing the balkans into the EU is likely to be the pin in the hand grenade that destroys the whole structure of EU stability this expansion mania needs to come to an end. Listen to western Europe they don't wan more enlargement or more lame ducks.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
M M Feb 4, 2018

You want a solution for "Macedonia", it should be unified with Greece. The dysfunctional EU does not need another dysfunctional state to overburden with debt. Adding another dysfunctional state goes against the "Grand Unification" project or ideal of the EU establishment. The EU energy is better spent on unifying Cyprus (which will never happen). If it was not for the defunct German armouries that were sold to Greece, may be the Greek army would have resolved this conflict long ago.
- Steve Hurst Feb 5, 2018
  
  Arrhichion
  A new reply to this comment has been posted.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
M M Feb 4, 2018

The EU establishment must keep its hands, feets and minds off the Balkans. There isn't a single person or being in the EU Institutions that is capable of doing or accepting anything constructive. The EU is playing with fire with the Macedonia issue. Putting pressure and black-mailing the latest Greek Traitor can only ignite an all out war, yet again, originating from the East. The events and streets demonstrations that have and are taking place in Greece and in many European capitals and US cities say it all. If the EU / US establishments do not listen to the voices of the people, which they won't, they will have only themselves to blame. History can only repeat itself.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Branimir Stojancic Feb 4, 2018

Matter analysis, without depth analysis of the problem, even in this small area. A very burdensome analysis of Russian influence, without a substantive question: What have we done, why the influence of Russia and China is so great and attractive to states and peoples, why we did not invest in traffic and other infrastructure, because EU justice reforms failed through their offices and various mediators, where are the vast euries that have come to reform? Will the change of name of the airport really lead to approach, when Macedonia is full of names, monuments, sculptures, squares, financed by the same EU. Many questions, essential, are not even touched. Only fear was shown of Russian influence, and financial, and the biggest companies and banks are from the EU countries. What then are you waiting for, how will you respond by setting a date? So the peoples of these countries had the opportunity to see on the example of Greece.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Branimir Stojancic Feb 4, 2018

Interestingly, besides the name, the important indicators of the crisis that this country faces are neglected, is one of the causes of the problem huge? Does it lead to tension and a crisis in ethnic division? There is no word about ethnic division, which is a threat to swallow the whole country.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Branimir Stojancic Feb 4, 2018

Interesting is the statement on the progress of the Western Balkans, especially in the context of the murder, which probably reflects this progress, and especially in comparison with national and radical forces, whether this progress is reflected in the fact that they are in power in almost all countries, are past. There are not a few parts of the column.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Emanuel Müller Feb 2, 2018

Meta-ethnic cleansing aka cultural cleansing can arguably prevent ethnic cleansing, this might point to the hypothesis that spiritual cleansing might prevent cultural cleansing. So spiritual cleansing, aka the overcoming of duality, might be able to prevent cultural cleansing, that itself can prevent ethnic cleansing, this amounts to the vision of the structure of the human being as a body containing a soul, itself containing a spirit. The internalisation of the rule of law seems similar the implantation of a replacement or surrogate soul into this populations.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
j. von Hettlingen Feb 1, 2018

Guy Verhofstadt urges the EU to "keep the Western Balkans within the European fold" to prevent the region from returning to the bloody ethnic conflict of the 1990s, and pivoting to Russia and China, "as has been the trend in recent years." He says the new "Enlargement Strategy" that the European Commission plans to adopt in February, "will set a target date of 2025 for the accession of Serbia and Montenegro." This might also help Kosovo and Serbia promote confidence-building efforts and ease tensions.
The question is whether the "European-led reforms" in these new potential EU members are of long-term sustainability to qualify for membership? Shouldn't the EU learn from past lessons? The 2004 Eastern Enlargement admitted Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, Poland, Slovakia, and Slovenia into the EU. The 2007 enlargement saw the accession of Bulgaria and Romania. Today only the Baltic States can be seen as both reliable and respectable members.
In retrospect the extension of EU membership to countries like the Czech Republic, Hungary, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, Bulgaria and Romania may have been premature. The lesson is that it takes decades for Eastern Europe and its citizens to adjust themselves to Western values. Self-determination and consumerism alone do not make people more democratic. The first bunch of politicians that emerged after the fall of the Soviet Union made up of enthusiastic, pro-EU and reform-minded politicians. In recent years, Hungary, Poland, the Czech Republic and Slovakia are governed by illiberal anti-EU parties.
Even after their countries gained independence following the fall of the Soviet Union, people still rally behind strong leaders. Although they don't want to be ruled by a “dictatorship of the proletariat”, they support populist leaders, as long as they are provided for. Tapping into anti-multicultural sentiments, populist, autocratic leaders in Eastern Europe defend a conservative, nationalist and nativist agenda. They milk benefits from the EU, while violating EU laws and eroding its liberal order.
In the face of the illiberal democracies in Eastern Europe, it raises doubts about admitting countries in the Western Balkans, where crime and corruption are pervasive, with judicial reforms taking the backseat.
Macedonia was spared the inter-ethnic violence that raged in the Balkans following the break-up of Yugoslavia in the early 1990s. but it came close to civil war a decade after independence. The country has been without a functioning government since 2015, following a wiretapping scandal that brought down the ruling nationalist party bloc. Social Democratic leader Zoran Zaev and his coalition partners representing Macedonia's ethnic Albanian minority. The president is wary of empowering Macedonia's ethnic Albanians, its largest minority, and thereby pose a threat to sovereignty. The country's name remains a contentious issue, because Greeks fear that its name could be linked to their northern region of Macedonia.
Montenegro emerged as a sovereign state after just over 55% of the population opted for independence in a May 2006 referendum, ending the Union of Serbia and Montenegro, which was created only three years earlier out of the remnant of the former Yugoslavia.The country is moving towards further integration with the West. A NATO membership since 2017 it aspires to join the EU. Others like Bosnia and Herzegovina face political resistance from the EU or their neighbours.
The author says, "Russia clearly has an interest in discouraging Western Balkan countries from pursuing NATO and EU membership, which is all the more reason for the EU to step up its engagement in the region." But what EU Commission President Jean-Claude Juncker did in his 2017 “State of the Union” address - calling for a “credible enlargement perspective” for the region, may instill unrealistic hope, that would end up in disappointment. There is little appetite within the EU for absorbing more new members just for the sake of preventing Moscow from bringing them in the Russian fold. If these countries can not get their act together, like putting their houses in order, they will only pose problems to the already crisis-ridden EU once they become members.
- Henk Crop Feb 2, 2018
  
  J. Yesterday there was a report that Juncker wanted Bulgaria to join Schengen and take over the task of stopping illegal immigrants. However they had only a simple fence kids could easily cross and guards accepting brides.
  Juncker shows again that he does not care what happens to the people in the EU as long as he can continue building his cathedral. The people have to pay and get crime in return.
  A new reply to this comment has been posted.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Henk Crop Feb 1, 2018

The Western Balkans countries live isolated and are divided by century old religious conflicts.
They look like Europeans and often speak the same language, but their differences remain.
It is an illusion that an EU membership will resolve all that.
The immense Brussels naive interferense has proven to be very dangerous.
The EU contributed greatly to the conflict between Russia and Ukraine.
I still recall the pictures of mr. Verhofstad on Maidan square calling the Ukainians the real Europeans.
On the Balkan conflict the EU needed the US to save them.
On the local level: the Albanians, not even EU members, have taken over to-day the drugtrade in the streets of Rotterdam.
We must set up a special relation for these countries, but exclude EU membership for many decades to come.
In general, Brussels is suffering from imperial overstretch. They are the good people, but to naive to operate effectively in the international environment. Examples: the bombing of Lybia, in Syria they delayed peace negotiations, their disruptive immigration policy, new is a special relationship with the colonies of the former French empire in Africa.
- Steve Hurst Feb 1, 2018
  
  There was a report (which now has disappeared from the internet) that circa 2005 the then US ambassador in Ukraine advised Washington to the effect that Russia would not happily let the Naval Fleet base at Sebastopol go under EU control at any point. I presume the info is lodged with Wikileaks but have no way of verifying it. It would be like Pearl Harbour in Hawaii coming under Russian control if Hawaii activists wanted to secede, it would cause strategic concern. This geopolitical dabbling is dangerous whether it is EU or Russia or Other inspired
  - Henk Crop Feb 2, 2018
    
    Steve. I recall a press report at that time whereby Rumania and Bulgaria, then new NATO members, called upon the NATO to form a Black Sea Fleet.
    Now they are still surprised that Russia took over the Crimea.
    A new reply to this comment has been posted.
  A new reply to this comment has been posted.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.
Steve Hurst Jan 31, 2018

How very 19th century geopolitical, even the same humanitarian claims, the superior to uplift the inferior for the greater good mentality, but also for the security of the superior - as a side issue of course. The arrogance of belief that the answers are known by an outsider. 'Our relations... in the forty years ...were successively those of blundering interference and of unmasterly inactivity' Lord Curzon 1889 commenting on The Great Game. 'Beyond these fundamental imperatives, the region will also need massive investments in transportation and communications infrastructure, to connect it to the rest of Europe' Guy V. This also is very 19th century, the American railroad development model. It did quell the Wild West as part of the Manifest Destiny program. When such 19th century grandiose strategies, which have questionable attributes, are proposed in the 21st century I worry. I would much prefer to hear what the individuals in the Balkans think and aspire to rather than what medicine Guy V thinks should be prescribed because at the end of the day resolution to conflict has to come from within those countries.
A new reply to this comment has been posted.

http://prosyn.org/WKbJjpI/ar;

إكمال المهمة المطلوب تنفيذها في غرب البلقان

To continue reading, please log in or enter your email address.

Featured

MAD About Sino-American Trade

Good Politics, Bad Economics

Japan’s Successful Economic Model

The Immorality of Boris Johnson and Donald Trump

The US Will Lose Its Trade War with China

New Comment

Email this piece to a friend

Contact us

Handpicked to read next

The Balkans Between Competing Poles

The US Will Lose Its Trade War with China

The Evolution of Globalization

Governments Must Stand Up for Health

Israel Chooses Identity Over Democracy

Fresh Momentum for the Balkans

The Left Will Decide Poland’s Future

Japan’s Successful Economic Model

Good Politics, Bad Economics

Cookies and Privacy

Log in/Register