Opening the Balkans
NEW YORK: Yugoslavia's President Milosevic has succumbed to the military might of NATO and we can sigh with relief. To justify our intervention, however, we must now assure a better future not only for the people of Kosovo, but for the whole region, including the rump of Yugoslavia which remains in Mr Milosovic's hands. We cannot go on reacting to crises as they arise in the Balkans, especially as our actions can have such severe unintended and adverse consequences. We must bring a positive, constructive vision to bear, the vision that has created the European Union.
The Balkans cannot be reconstructed on the basis of nation states. We have seen that the attempt to establish ethnic homogeneity can lead to intolerable atrocities, human suffering and destruction. It is also impractical. The population of Yugoslavia, even after the exclusion of Kosovo, remains about 25% non-Serb. The only way to peace and prosperity is to create an open society in which the state plays a less dominant role and borders diminish in importance. That is the road that the European Union has chosen.
The idea of the open society was first proposed by Henry Bergson in his "Two Sources of Religion and Morality" (1932). He distinguished between a tribal idea of morality and a universal idea. The former leads to a closed society; the latter to an open society. The concept was further developed by Karl Popper in his famous book "The Open Society and its Enemies" where he showed that the open society may also be threatened by universal ideas if they claim a monopoly of the truth; but the problems of the region are best understood in terms of Bergson's formulation. In the wars of the Yugoslav succession we have seen a struggle between the ethnic and the civic concepts of citizenship. In Yugoslavia the civic concept lost out and Yugoslavia disintegrated. In Western Europe the civic concept prevailed and the integration of Europe stands in stark contrast with the disintegration of Yugoslavia. The European Union must now extend its protective umbrella over the region.
We hope you're enjoying Project Syndicate.
To continue reading, subscribe now.
Get unlimited access to PS premium content, including in-depth commentaries, book reviews, exclusive interviews, On Point, the Big Picture, the PS Archive, and our annual year-ahead magazine.
Already have an account or want to create one? Log in