From Bismarck to Bankruptcy?

The modern welfare state was created by Germany's "Iron Chancellor," Otto von Bismarck, who in the 1880’s introduced sickness, accident, and old-age insurance. More than a century later, the problems associated with Bismarck's original plan remain our own.

PRINCETON – Democracies find it hard to deal with inter-generational social transfers, and with pensions in particular. Like all such transfers, the demand for more security in old age produces a fierce clash of opposing interests. In favorable circumstances, those clashes are resolved by the promise and reality of economic growth. When times are bad, it is hard to provide a solution that is not based on deceit and lies.

The modern welfare state has a peculiar patron: Germany’s “Iron Chancellor,” Otto von Bismarck, who pushed through the big reforms of the 1880’s on sickness, accident, and old-age insurance against liberal parliamentary opponents. The motivation behind the reforms was avowedly cynical – to buy off labor protest, or, as he put it, to give the working class an interest in the state.

The reforms were the product of a state that was only partly democratic – and in large measure still authoritarian. Only someone in Bismarck’s position could shift social entitlements so decisively. For more accountable politicians, large-scale reform of social insurance – as the US has found in the case of healthcare reform – is immensely divisive.

To continue reading, please log in or enter your email address.

Registration is quick and easy and requires only your email address. If you already have an account with us, please log in. Or subscribe now for unlimited access.


Log in;