Spain On The Brink Of A Downgrade To Junk
The Baa3 long term debt rating of the Spanish government remains on review for possible downgrade. The review commenced on 13 June 2012 and will likely continue through the end of September because of pending information on:
(1) the scope of the bank recapitalisation needs;
(2) the nature and size of support mechanisms available under the European Stability Mechanism (ESM) in light the upcoming German Constitutional court ruling; and
(3) potential changes and additions to the existing crisis-management framework as policymakers reconvene in the next few weeks to discuss policy options in a number of areas, including the further advancement of a banking union.
--Moody’s, Aug. 30th, 2012
The Year Ahead 2018
The world’s leading thinkers and policymakers examine what’s come apart in the past year, and anticipate what will define the year ahead.
Moody’s said in August that it would conclude its review of Spain’s near-junk rating by the end of September, which I guess means the end of this week. They now have answers to all three open questions listed above, so they need to decide.
Moody’s must decide whether (in its opinion) Spanish government bonds are suitable as an investment for fiduciaries, or should instead be viewed as a speculative investment unsuitable for widows and orphans. An end of the review with a confirmation at Baa3 would seem to be out of the question. Either they will extend yet further the review (punt), or take the rating to Ba1 or Ba2.
While an opinion about the future can await additional information, it is at risk of becoming journalism rather than opinion. Moody’s could wait forever to decide the review but that wouldn't be very helpful to investors.
My guess is that the rating will go to Ba2 with a negative outlook. In my opinion, while Spain will be helped in the short-term by the eurozone’s “crisis-management framework”, it is doomed in the end to default and redenomination, as long as the ECB sticks to its suicidal price-stability mandate. Moody’s view appears to be bit more nuanced in favor of the possible success of the muddle-through scenario, but investment grade seems inappropriate for a country with spiralling debt, an intractable fiscal deficit, and 6% bond yields. It just smells speculative.
Assuming Spain’s bond rating goes to junk, yields should rise slightly, although most investment grade portfolios dumped Spanish risk long ago. But there will be a few stragglers forced to sell by the downgrade. Of course, the downgrade to junk and the falling price of Spanish bonds will have no impact on the ECB’s collateral standards or on European bank accounting. Spain remains risk-free in the Alice-in-Wonderland that is Europe. “We don’t need anglosaxon ratings on European bonds.”
Presumably, the downgrade will hasten Rajoy’s non-application application to Europe for help, although it really isn’t up to him. It’s up to Draghi, and how long he can wait for the Spanish banks to be recapitalized to his satisfaction. He can put his foot on the oxygen hose whenever he chooses. But even Sr. Draghi must view Spanish government bonds at 100 cents on the euro, because he too lives in Wonderland.