Economics for the Interested Amateur #1: Deleveraging
Recently I was asked a very reasonable question. When households and firms are deleveraging, why should this decrease demand? Intuitively, when one household decides to pay back debt, that household’s wealth decreases and the wealth of the creditor increases. While the debtor can spend less, the creditor can spend more.
For a limited time only, get unlimited access to On Point, The Big Picture, and the PS Archive, plus our annual magazine, for less than $2 a week.
Lending is a transfer between lenders, who have more money than they wish to spend, to borrowers, who wish to spend more than their current income. It does not follow that if borrowers pay back lenders, the lenders will then spend more. We need to distinguish between asset swaps and spending decisions. The borrower wants to reduce debt and decides to consume less to do so. The lender therefore has cash instead of loans on the books – but that does not mean he or she will spend more. In fact, the recipient is likely to hoard the money paid back if there is an increase in economic uncertainty, in which case the transfer of asset leads to a fall in demand. This is exactly what the banks have been doing in the recent crisis.