Exit from comment view mode. Click to hide this space
Email | Print

Taiwan's Democratic Labor Pains

Young democracies can be cruel: their voters are often as unforgiving as political opponents. The two weeks since Taiwan's disputed presidential election of March 20 - only the third such democratic vote in the country's history - has tested this truism almost to the breaking point. Taiwan's young democracy must now cope with the balancing act that President Chen Shui-bian's re-election has thrust upon it.

While canvassing for votes in his hometown in southern Taiwan on the eve of the election, President Chen and Vice President Annette Lu were both wounded by an assassin's bullet. The sympathy this secured gave the President his razor-thin margin of victory - with just 50.1% of the votes - over Lien Chan, the candidate of the Kuomintang Party and People's First Party (KMT-PFP) coalition. Opposition street protests and shouts that the assassination was stage followed. A recount was demanded.

None of this is surprising, because Taiwan's society is evenly and deeply polarized. President Chen's Democratic Progressive Party (DPP) called for "one country on each side of the Taiwan Strait" and for "preventing the return of an alien regime" (meaning the KMT, which came to Taiwan in 1949). But while Chen's campaign to safeguard Taiwan against threats from mainland China clearly galvanized the party's supporters, it made the uncommitted nervous and the rival KMT angry.

For the KMT-PFP coalition, the campaign was a virtual holy war, conducted not only to revive an ailing economy, but also to keep the country's official name: the "Republic of China." With so much at stake, both camps mobilized millions of people.

President Chen upped the stakes even more by holding Taiwan's first-ever popular referendum. It called for beefing up Taiwan's defense in the face of mainland China's missile threats and for building a peaceful framework of relations across the strait that separates Taiwan from the mainland. Not only did China denounce the referendum as provocative, but so did the US President George W. Bush.

In the weeks since the vote, Taiwan has staggered ahead. President Chen agreed to a recount. But the questions on everyone's lips are whether the loser of the recount will accept the result, and whether Taiwan's young democracy can survive this tumult?

For the most important issue facing Taiwan today is not re-unification with China, but consolidating and deepening our democratic institutions. Traditions of tolerance must replace the turbulence that has so far dominated the building of Taiwan's democracy.

The one benefit to be gained from the referendum is that, for the first time, Taiwan's citizens were asked to debate issues related to national defense and cross-Strait relations. Any citizen could take part in one of ten nationally televised debates and argue with government officials.

Moreover, the presidential candidates themselves engaged in two rounds of televised debates and gave another two televised speeches - a political openness new to Taiwan and unique in the Chinese political world. Although China's rulers dismissed the election, Taiwan's open democratic exercises will have vast repercussions for other Chinese political communities in their pursuit of greater political pluralism.

From this perspective, Taiwan's democratic traditions can only grow stronger. The DPP is a relatively young party, formed only in 1986. For a long time, indeed, Taiwan was overshadowed by the KMT. That dominance is now definitively a thing of the past. The uneven distribution of power between the two parties had many predicting a victory for the KMT-PFP coalition. Indeed, the DPP had never been able to win more than 40% of the vote previously. Its victory has now made it a fixture on the political landscape.

Having ruled for four years, the DPP has already redrawn Taiwan's political map. Its calls for more reforms, its belief in Taiwan, and the urgency of its appeal to defend the island against undue influence from China have now captured the allegiance of a small majority of the population. Yet this should not be considered an outright victory for Taiwanese nationalism.

Were it not for the shooting incident on the election's eve, the opposition might have eked out a victory, with the soft economy the deciding factor. The slim majority, and the clear differences between the two political camps, will assure a robust two-party system in the future.

But more than two strong parties have emerged from the campaign. The law, too, is giving democracy here a boost.

For example, the two parties are now engaged in tense negotiations to amend the Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election and Recall Law to avert any repeat of the current confused circumstances surrounding the current recount. In the future a compulsory recount will be held should the winning margin be less than 1%. A "sunshine law" to regulate political donations was enacted before the ballots were cast. The finances of the president and his/her family will henceforth be more strictly monitored.

Taiwan's democratic experiences are messy, but no messier than the vote that brought President Bush to power four years ago. Yes, Taiwan's recent vote will leave a divided country behind, but those divisions are democratic divisions, and people are now organizing for the next elections. Instead of writing off Taiwan's democratic experiment as doomed to instability or worse, the disputed vote will help consolidate and invigorate our democratic order.

Reprinting material from this Web site without written consent from Project Syndicate is a violation of international copyright law. To secure permission, please contact us.

Exit from comment view mode. Click to hide this space

Comments (0)

You need to login in order to leave a comment. If you do not yet have an account, please register.

Show comments of
close

The two commenting options explained

Watch a 1 minute video
to discover how you can comment on the entire article or a specific paragraph. The two images below also explain the two ways of commenting.

1) Entire article comment
Once logged in, simply click inside the comment box where it says "Enter text here." Enter and post your comment.

2) Paragraph comment
Please log in first. Then click to the left of the desired paragraph. Your cursor will automatically move to the comments box. Enter and post your comment.

Top Project Syndicate commentaries

Email this article

Your name is required.

Your email is required.


Your friend's name is required.

Your friend's email is required.


A message is required.